The honest answer is that it is a much higher bar than people expect.
Home › Memphis Child Custody › What Makes a Parent Unfit
The Standard
People call asking how to prove the other parent is unfit. There is no unfit box a judge checks. What exists in Tennessee is the dependency and neglect statute, and that statute tells you exactly what makes a child dependent and neglected.
That distinction matters more than it sounds like it does, because it changes what you are actually asking a court to do.
The Part Nobody Wants to Hear
Here is the filter that almost nobody applies before calling a lawyer. Practically every parent in juvenile court is a bad parent in some respect. That is the population of that building. If bad parenting alone met the standard, the docket would be every case in Shelby County.
Dependency and neglect is reserved for children who should or could be removed. Not for a parent who is unreliable, disorganized, or infuriating. Not for a parent whose house is messier than yours. Not for a parent with a new partner you cannot stand.
If your honest situation is that the other parent is difficult and you want more time with your child, you do not have a dependency and neglect case. You have a custody modification case, and that is a different filing with a different standard.
What Actually Meets It
A drug exposed child is the clearest case there is. It is the single most common basis for a sustained dependency and neglect finding, and it moves fast.
A parent who has stopped being present, or who is not available because they are in custody, reaches the standard on its own facts.
Not a diagnosis by itself. A pattern that leaves a child unsafe or uncared for.
A child not in school. A child not receiving necessary medical care. A child not being vaccinated. These are less dramatic than the categories above and they come up constantly.
How a Case Starts
The Department of Children’s Services receives referrals. A teacher, a neighbor, a coach, a family member, a police officer. DCS investigates, and referrals that are sustained by the investigation go to their in-house attorneys, who file the dependency and neglect petition.
In some cases DCS will do an agency removal, or seek a protective custody order to remove the child immediately.
A private party can also file. That is often a relative already caring for a child who needs the court to make it official. If DCS has contacted you, read this first.
The Questions That Shape the Case
Every dependency and neglect matter turns on the same set of questions, and the answers determine what the case actually is.
That last one decides more outcomes than people realize. A parent with a problem the court believes can be addressed is in a very different position from a parent without one.
Two Cases at Once
Dependency and neglect and a custody and visitation case can run in parallel, on separate dockets, at the same time. The standard of review is not the same in both.
There are reasons to do that and reasons not to. It depends on what you are actually trying to accomplish and what the record in each case will look like to the other judge.
Also worth knowing: Eli’s Law means a prior dependency and neglect adjudication can create a presumption against a parent as to later children. A first case is never only a first case.
Your Attorney
William Young · Of Counsel · Juvenile Court
Attorney William Young practices in Shelby County Juvenile Court and handles dependency and neglect on both sides, defending parents against DCS and representing family members filing private party petitions to protect a child.
Juvenile court → · Emergency custody → · Eli’s Law → · About William Young →
Common Questions
There is no separate unfit standard. What exists is the dependency and neglect statute, which sets out what makes a child dependent and neglected. The question a court is answering is not whether someone is a bad parent. It is whether the child should or could be removed from that parent.
No. Practically every parent in juvenile court is a bad parent in some respect, and dependency and neglect is reserved for children who could be removed. A parent who is unreliable, disorganized, or difficult does not meet that standard. That situation is a custody modification, which is a different filing.
A drug exposed child is the clearest case. Abandonment, incarceration, a suicide attempt, severe and persistent mental illness, and chronic drug or alcohol use all come up. So do the less dramatic ones: a child not in school, a child not receiving necessary medical care, a child not being vaccinated.
Usually the Department of Children's Services. DCS receives referrals from teachers, neighbors, coaches, family members, or police, investigates them, and sends sustained referrals to its in-house attorneys, who file the petition. A private party such as a relative already caring for the child can also file.
No. Changing an existing custody order requires a material change in circumstances and a best interest analysis under the statutory factors. That is a lower bar than dependency and neglect and it is a separate filing.
Yes. They run in parallel on separate dockets, and the standard of review is different in each. There are strategic reasons to do that and reasons not to, depending on what the record in each case will look like to the other judge.
Who filed the petition, whether a protective custody order is being pursued, whether severe abuse is alleged, whether reunification will be an option if the petition is sustained, and whether there are services or treatment the parent can receive that address the problem. That last question decides a great many outcomes.
It can. Under Eli's Law, at Tennessee Code Annotated section 37-1-188, a prior adjudication combined with the first child remaining in DCS custody creates a presumption as to subsequent children. It is a rebuttable presumption, but it changes the starting position of the case.
Free consultation. Call and find out whether you have a dependency and neglect case or a custody case.