What you say could be the biggest mistake of your life.
Home › Memphis Child Custody › Should I Talk to DCS?
The Short Answer
DCS — the Tennessee Department of Children's Services — is not a neutral party. When a DCS employee shows up at your door, they are there to conduct an investigation. They are trained observers with a specific goal. What you say, what you sign, how your home looks, how it smells, what they can hear — all of it is being observed, documented, and potentially used in a court proceeding that could result in your child being removed from your home.
This is not about being uncooperative. This is about understanding what you are dealing with. DCS employees are not there to help you explain yourself. They are there to gather information. The most important thing you can do in the first moments of a DCS contact is stop, step outside, and call an attorney.
What DCS Is Trained to Do
DCS employees receive training in how to conduct investigations, how to talk to parents and children, and how to document what they observe. They are trained to move fast. They know that the first moments of contact — before you have spoken to an attorney, before you understand what is happening — are the moments when parents say things they cannot take back.
DCS employees will observe everything. What your home looks like. What it smells like. What sounds they can hear. What your children look like. How you respond to their questions. Whether you seem cooperative or defensive. Whether your children seem comfortable or afraid. All of it goes into their report. All of it can be used in court.
They may tell you that cooperating will make things easier. They may suggest that having nothing to hide means you should have no problem answering questions. These are things trained investigators say. A statement you make voluntarily to a DCS employee can be used in a dependency and neglect proceeding — and there is no equivalent of Miranda rights requiring them to warn you of that before you speak.
At the Door
Step outside. Do not invite them in. Do not let them in without a court order. Tell them you are calling an attorney and that you will have your attorney contact them. Then call immediately.
Do not slam the door. Do not be hostile. Do not argue. Be calm, be polite, and say as little as possible. You do not have to explain yourself. You do not have to answer their questions. You do not have to sign anything they hand you.
DCS cannot enter your home without your consent or a court order. If they have reason to believe a child is in immediate danger, they can involve law enforcement. If law enforcement arrives with them, the situation has escalated and you need an attorney immediately.
Removal
Yes. DCS can remove a child immediately if they determine the child is in danger. Danger is a term they interpret subjectively. It can be as potentially minor as a cluttered home or a child going to school in dirty clothes, or as serious as allegations of physical or sexual abuse, domestic violence in the child's presence, or drug use.
They do not need a court order to remove a child in an emergency. They will seek one after the fact — typically within days — at a preliminary hearing where a judge reviews whether removal was appropriate. That preliminary hearing is your first real opportunity to be heard, and what happens there can shape the entire case. Do not appear at that hearing without an attorney.
This Can Happen to Anyone
The following is a hypothetical written to illustrate how Tennessee's dependency and neglect process works. It is not based on any client or any case.
Picture an ordinary family. Two parents, both working. Two young children. No criminal record, no prior contact with the department, nothing in their history that would draw anyone's attention.
One of the children has a medical issue. A doctor recommends a course of treatment. The parents have questions. They want a second opinion, or they want to wait, or they want to try something else first — the kind of decision families make in doctors' offices every day. Somewhere in that process, a mandatory reporter decides the disagreement is worth a phone call.
That call is all it takes to open an investigation. From that moment forward, the parents are subjects of a state case, and they are the last people to find out how serious it has become. A caseworker takes an interest. The file grows. The parents believe they are cooperating with a misunderstanding that will resolve itself.
Then the state files an ex parte emergency petition to remove the child. Ex parte means the parents are not there. They do not respond, because no one told them it was happening. And because the petition is filed ex parte, the record is sealed — even afterward, the parents cannot see the full set of allegations made against them.
A judge may deny that petition. The case does not end. A Guardian ad Litem is appointed. The parents hire an attorney. They are now in litigation with the State of Tennessee over whether they get to keep their child, and the underlying dispute was a treatment decision.
And because there is a second child in the home, Eli's Law comes into play. Under TCA § 37-1-188, a dependency and neglect finding on the older child creates a legal presumption against the parents as to the younger one. One phone call. One caseworker. One petition. A family with two children looking at losing both.
Nothing in that sequence requires anyone to have hurt a child. It requires a phone call. That is how fast these cases move, and that is why you do not open the door and start talking.
Prior Adjudications
Under TCA § 37-1-188 — known as Eli's Law — if you have previously had a child removed for dependency and neglect and that child remains in DCS custody, there is a legal presumption that any subsequent child you have may also be dependent or neglected. DCS is required to notify the court when they learn of a new birth. The court must immediately schedule a hearing.
Tennessee has not created a formal registry for parents with prior D&N adjudications. Eli's Law effectively accomplishes the same thing. If you have a prior adjudication, call an attorney before DCS contacts you about a new child — not after.
The question underneath a DCS investigation is whether a court would find the child dependent and neglected. That standard is higher than most people assume. What makes a parent unfit →
Your Attorney
William Young · Of Counsel · Juvenile Court & DUI
Attorney William Young has over 15 years of experience in Shelby County Juvenile Court. He handles DCS investigations, dependency and neglect cases, and represents both parents defending against removal and family members seeking to protect a child. If DCS has contacted you or you believe a DCS investigation is coming, call before they arrive.
Common Questions
No. Do not talk to DCS and do not sign anything. DCS employees are trained to move fast. They have a playbook. What you say, what you sign, even how your home looks, smells, and sounds to DCS employees all matters. Call an attorney immediately before saying anything.
Not without a court order. DCS cannot enter your home without your consent or a court order. Do not slam the door — step outside, tell them you are calling an attorney, and call immediately.
Yes. DCS can remove a child immediately if they determine the child is in danger. Danger is a term they interpret subjectively — it can be as minor as a cluttered home or as serious as allegations of abuse. Do not give them a reason to act. Call an attorney first.
Refusing to speak with DCS is not an admission of guilt. You have the right to remain silent and the right to have an attorney present. Invoking those rights is not something DCS can use against you as evidence of wrongdoing. What you say voluntarily, however, can and will be used in any subsequent court proceeding.
Not without speaking with an attorney first. A safety plan may seem like a cooperative gesture. It creates legal obligations and can be used as an admission in subsequent proceedings.
Call an attorney immediately. Do not speak with DCS, do not sign any documents, and do not allow them into your home without a court order. Tell them you are represented by an attorney and that all contact should go through counsel. Then call (901) 578-1515.
Yes. DCS employees are trained observers. What your home looks like, smells like, and sounds like during their visit is all part of what they report. A cluttered home, an odor, a child's appearance, how you respond — all of it is observed and documented.
Under TCA § 37-1-188, if you have previously had a child removed for dependency and neglect and that child remains in DCS custody, there is a legal presumption that any subsequent child you have may also be dependent or neglected. DCS must notify the court when they learn of a new birth, and the court must immediately schedule a hearing. If you have a prior D&N adjudication and are expecting or have recently had a child, call an attorney before DCS contacts you.
Attorney William Young — Shelby County Juvenile Court. Free consultation.