The Most Common Question in a Divorce Consult — and the Most Contested Issue in a Divorce Case
Home › Memphis Divorce › Alimony
Memphis Alimony Attorney
Almost every divorce consultation that involves a significant income disparity between spouses eventually comes around to the same question: what about alimony? It is the most emotionally charged issue in most divorce cases — and one of the most misunderstood.
For one spouse, it is a bitter pill. For the other, it is an earned entitlement — the financial recognition of years of sacrifice, career decisions made for the benefit of the family, and contributions that don't show up on a pay stub. Both perspectives have merit. Courts in Shelby County have seen every version of this argument, and they have a framework for sorting through it.
The analysis ultimately comes down to two questions: does the requesting spouse need it, and can the paying spouse afford it. Everything else flows from there.
What Courts Look At
Courts look at the financial reality of the spouse requesting support. What do they earn — or what can they earn? Have they been out of the workforce? Are they the primary caregiver for children? Did they sacrifice career development to support the family or their spouse's career? A spouse who has been financially dependent throughout the marriage, who gave up professional opportunities, or who has been raising children rather than building a career, carries a strong argument for support.
Courts also look at whether the requesting spouse is purposefully underemployed — choosing not to work or working below their capability when they are fully capable of earning more. A spouse who voluntarily limits their income will find the court less sympathetic.
Courts look at gross income. That is where it starts — and for many judges, that is also where it ends. The reality of what someone actually takes home after taxes, existing obligations, and cost of living often receives less scrutiny than it deserves. If an alimony order represents 20% of your gross income, the court may approve it without fully accounting for the fact that 20% of gross is a much larger percentage of what you actually have available to spend.
This is not a complaint about the system — it is a reality of it. Understanding it matters, because the way your financial picture is presented to the court has a direct impact on the outcome. Having an attorney who can present a complete and accurate financial picture — not just a gross income number — is essential.
Shelby County courts are pragmatic. If one spouse has been financially supporting the other throughout the marriage — paying the bills, covering expenses, maintaining a certain standard of living — the court's tendency is to maintain that status quo during and after the divorce. The longer the marriage and the more established the financial dynamic, the more weight this history carries.
Types of Alimony in Tennessee
Tennessee recognizes four types of alimony. In Shelby County, two of them — transitional and rehabilitative — are the most common outcomes in most divorce cases.
Transitional alimony is designed to help a spouse adjust to their new financial reality after a divorce. It is time-limited — it ends on a date certain. The purpose is to bridge the gap between the financial life of the marriage and the financial life of the newly single spouse. Courts award it when the requesting spouse needs adjustment support but is already capable of being self-sufficient or will be in a defined period of time.
Rehabilitative alimony is designed to help a spouse become self-sufficient through education, job training, or career development. It ends when the recipient achieves a defined goal or after a set period. Courts award it when the requesting spouse needs time and resources to build the earning capacity they don't currently have — often because they stepped away from a career to raise children or support the family.
A lump-sum payment, paid all at once or in installments over a defined period. Once ordered, it generally cannot be modified. Less common in standard divorce cases but used in specific circumstances, particularly in high-asset divorces where a clean financial break is preferred.
Long-term periodic payments that continue indefinitely — until the recipient remarries, either spouse dies, or the court modifies the order. Reserved for cases where the requesting spouse cannot reasonably be expected to become self-supporting, typically in long marriages where one spouse has been entirely out of the workforce for many years. Less common in Shelby County than transitional or rehabilitative alimony.
While the Divorce Is Pending
Pendente lite is temporary support ordered while the divorce is still pending — before it is finalized. It maintains the financial status quo during the divorce process. In cases involving children, pendente lite hearings also address temporary child support. In cases without children, they can be focused entirely on temporary alimony and attorney's fees.
In Shelby County, pendente lite hearings are heard by divorce referees — not judges. This distinction matters more than most people realize.
A referee handling a pendente lite hearing is not looking at the full picture of the divorce. They are making a temporary decision about immediate financial needs. They are not weighing the final equitable distribution of assets, the long-term earning trajectory of both spouses, or the complete financial history of the marriage. They are looking at right now — who needs money and who has it.
That narrower lens creates a strategic dynamic. If you are the spouse requesting temporary support, a pendente lite hearing in front of a referee is often more favorable than waiting for a judge to hear the issue in the context of the full case. The referee's simplified view tends to favor immediate need. If you are the spouse who would be paying, the opposite is often true — settling a pendente lite issue before the hearing is frequently a better outcome than letting a referee set the temporary order, because a temporary order has a way of becoming the baseline expectation for the final divorce.
Does Infidelity Matter?
Tennessee law allows courts to consider marital fault — including infidelity — in alimony decisions. Whether it actually changes the outcome depends almost entirely on the financial scale of the case.
In high-asset divorces, where the financial stakes are large enough to justify extensive litigation, infidelity can matter significantly. Attorneys litigate it, judges weigh it, and it can move the needle on both the amount and duration of alimony.
In cases where the parties are not wealthy, the practical reality is different. Courts tend to focus their attention on financial need and ability to pay — the two questions that matter most — and infidelity rarely changes the outcome in a meaningful way. The judge is not indifferent to it, but the financial analysis tends to dominate.
If you are counting on infidelity to dramatically change your alimony outcome in a case without significant assets, temper that expectation. If you are in a high-asset case, it is a different conversation.
Custody is a separate question, and the answer there is different. Does cheating affect custody in Tennessee?
Your Attorney
Sam Jaber · Divorce & Family Law · Practicing Since 2011
Attorney Sam Jaber has handled hundreds of divorce cases in Shelby County — contested, uncontested, high-asset, and everything in between. Alimony comes up in nearly every case involving a significant income disparity, and Sam has seen every version of it. He will give you an honest, direct assessment of what the court is likely to do based on the specific financial facts of your situation.
Common Questions
Alimony — also called spousal support — is a court-ordered payment from one spouse to the other after a divorce. Tennessee recognizes four types: transitional alimony, rehabilitative alimony, alimony in solido (a lump sum), and alimony in futuro (long-term periodic payments). In Shelby County, transitional and rehabilitative alimony are the most common outcomes in most divorce cases.
Does the requesting spouse need it, and can the paying spouse afford it. Those two questions drive the analysis. Courts also look heavily at the history of the marriage — if one spouse has been financially supporting the other throughout the marriage, Shelby County courts tend to maintain that status quo. A spouse who has been out of the workforce, raised children, or sacrificed career development for the marriage carries a strong argument for support.
Transitional alimony is designed to help a spouse adjust to their new financial situation after divorce — it's time-limited and intended to bridge the gap. Rehabilitative alimony is designed to help a spouse become self-sufficient — typically by completing education or job training. Both are common in Shelby County. Rehabilitative alimony ends when the recipient achieves a defined goal or after a set period. Transitional alimony ends on a date certain.
Pendente lite alimony is temporary support ordered while the divorce is still pending. It maintains the financial status quo during the divorce process. In Shelby County, pendente lite hearings are handled by divorce referees, not judges. These hearings often also address temporary attorney's fees. Understanding how referees approach these hearings — and the strategic implications of going forward versus settling — is one of the most important tactical decisions in a divorce case.
Technically yes — Tennessee law allows courts to consider marital fault, including infidelity, in alimony decisions. In practice, it depends heavily on the financial scale of the case. In high-asset divorces, infidelity can matter significantly. In cases where the parties are not wealthy, courts tend to focus almost entirely on financial need and ability to pay, and infidelity rarely changes the outcome in a meaningful way.
Yes — and it happens. Courts look at gross income figures and financial statements, but they don't always account for the full reality of what someone takes home after taxes, existing obligations, and living expenses. This is exactly why having an attorney who can present a complete and accurate financial picture to the court matters.
Yes. Tennessee courts can award temporary attorney's fees as part of a pendente lite order while the divorce is pending. This is particularly important when there is a significant income disparity between the spouses — the lower-earning spouse may be entitled to have some or all of their legal fees paid by the other spouse during the proceedings.
In practice, yes — income disparity is the primary driver. The spouse who earns more is typically the one who pays. Courts look at the actual financial picture of each spouse, their earning capacity, their career history, and their contributions to the marriage. A spouse who is purposefully underemployed or who chooses not to work when capable will find the court less sympathetic.
It depends on the type. Transitional and rehabilitative alimony are time-limited — they end on a date or when a specific goal is met. Alimony in futuro is long-term and can last indefinitely, but it is reserved for cases where one spouse cannot reasonably be expected to become self-supporting. Most Shelby County cases result in transitional or rehabilitative alimony with a defined end date.
Call Sam Jaber today. Honest answers about what the court is likely to do in your case.