It is not a review of the record. It is a brand new trial.
Home › Memphis Child Custody › Appealing a D&N Ruling
Where You Are
A dependency and neglect case moves through the same sequence every time. Find where you are before you read the rest of this.
What an Appeal Actually Is
This is the part people do not believe until they see it happen.
Tennessee Code Annotated § 37-1-159(a) provides that an appeal from a dependency and neglect ruling goes to circuit court, which “shall hear the testimony of witnesses and try the case de novo.”
De novo means from the beginning. The circuit judge is not reading a transcript looking for errors. Witnesses testify again. Evidence comes in again. The circuit court decides whether the child is dependent and neglected as though the juvenile court hearing never happened.
In a 2026 case out of Nashville, a grandmother won custody in juvenile court and the mother appealed to circuit. The circuit court held a two-day trial, heard from the grandmother, the child, the father, and the child’s counselor, and reached its own conclusion. That is what de novo means. It is not a formality.
The statute does not reserve the de novo appeal for parents. The Department of Children’s Services can appeal a case it lost in juvenile court and try it again in circuit, which is part of why the rule exists at all.
In Shelby County that rarely happens. DCS here carries a caseload heavy enough that appeals are not where the resources go. So while both sides technically get a second trial, in practice the parent is usually the one who takes it.
The Deadline
The appeal must be perfected within ten days, excluding nonjudicial days, following entry of the juvenile court’s order. Business days, not calendar days, which is a small mercy and still not much time.
Miss it and the ruling stands. There is no version of this where a good reason gets you back in.
Ordinarily, when the order is entered. But if the case was heard by a magistrate and you request a rehearing before the judge under § 37-1-107, the timing shifts. If no rehearing is requested, the expiration of the time to request one becomes the date of disposition for appeal purposes. If there is a rehearing, the appeal period starts the day after the disposition order is entered.
That review is worth understanding on its own. Attorney William Young has used the judicial review process to get cases redocketed that other attorneys had told their clients were finished.
Where the Child Lives
This is the first question every parent asks, and the answer is in the statute.
Section 37-1-159(b) says an appeal does not suspend the order of the juvenile court, and does not release the child from the custody of whatever person, institution, or agency the child was committed to.
The circuit court can make its own temporary disposition while the appeal is pending. But until it enters one, the juvenile court’s order remains in effect.
Also worth knowing: every party to the juvenile court proceeding is a party to the de novo appeal. Nobody gets left behind.
What Gets Retried
A dependency and neglect proceeding has two phases, and the appeal reaches both.
Whether the child is dependent and neglected, as defined at Tennessee Code Annotated § 37-1-102(b)(13). That definition is a list, and a case can be built on any part of it. Drug exposure. Abandonment. A parent who is incarcerated or unavailable. A child not receiving necessary care. A child left in a relative’s sole care for eighteen months. More on what actually meets that standard →
What happens to the child once the finding is made. Custody, placement, what a parent has to do to get the child back.
The standard of proof at adjudication is clear and convincing evidence, which is higher than the ordinary civil standard and lower than the criminal one.
After Circuit
If circuit court goes against you, the next step is the Court of Appeals. That one is a genuine appeal on the record, not another trial, and it is governed by the appellate rules rather than § 37-1-159.
In the Nashville case above, the mother lost in juvenile court, lost again after a two-day de novo trial in circuit, appealed to the Court of Appeals, and the Court of Appeals affirmed. Three courts, one outcome.
That is worth sitting with. A de novo appeal is a real second chance and it is not a reset button. The facts still have to be there.
Your Attorney
William Young · Of Counsel · Juvenile Court
Attorney William Young practices in Shelby County Juvenile Court and knows the rules of evidence and procedure cold, which in that building matters more than it should have to. He handles dependency and neglect on both sides, representing parents defending against the State and family members filing to protect a child, and has used the judicial review process under § 37-1-107 to get cases redocketed that other attorneys had called over.
Dependency & neglect → · Should I talk to DCS? → · Juvenile court → · About William Young →
Common Questions
Yes. Tennessee Code Annotated section 37-1-159(a) allows an appeal from a final order in a dependency and neglect proceeding to circuit court, which hears the testimony of witnesses and tries the case de novo.
From the beginning. The circuit court is not reviewing a transcript for errors. Witnesses testify again, evidence comes in again, and the circuit court decides whether the child is dependent and neglected as though the juvenile court hearing never happened.
Ten days, excluding nonjudicial days, following entry of the juvenile court's order. That is ten business days. Miss it and the ruling stands.
Ordinarily when the order is entered. If a magistrate heard the case and no rehearing before the judge is requested under section 37-1-107, the expiration of the time to request one becomes the date of disposition for appeal purposes. If there is a rehearing, the appeal period begins the day after the disposition order is entered.
Not automatically. Section 37-1-159(b) provides that an appeal does not suspend the juvenile court's order and does not release the child from the custody of whoever the child was committed to. The circuit court can enter its own temporary disposition, but until it does, the juvenile court's order stays in effect.
Yes. The de novo appeal is not reserved for parents, and the Department of Children's Services can appeal a case it lost in juvenile court and try it again in circuit. In Shelby County that rarely happens, because DCS here carries a caseload heavy enough that appeals are not where the resources go. In practice the parent is usually the one who takes the second trial.
Yes. The de novo appeal is heard in circuit court, which is a different court with a different judge from the juvenile court that entered the original ruling.
Both phases. Whether the child is dependent and neglected under Tennessee Code Annotated section 37-1-102(b)(13), and what disposition follows if that finding is made. The standard of proof at adjudication is clear and convincing evidence.
Everyone. Section 37-1-159 provides that all parties to the juvenile court proceeding are parties to the de novo appeal.
The next step is the Court of Appeals. That is an appeal on the record rather than another trial, and it is governed by the appellate rules. A 2026 Nashville case went exactly that route, and the Court of Appeals affirmed the circuit court.
It is a real second chance and it is not a reset. The facts still have to support your position. In the Nashville case the mother lost in juvenile court, lost again after a two-day trial in circuit, and lost at the Court of Appeals. Three courts, one outcome.
Free consultation. If juvenile court went against you, call before the clock runs out.